INTOSAI Working Group on the Audit of Privatisation
Fourteenth Meeting Marrakech, 16-18 October 2007 - Interactive voting results
INTOSAI Working Group on the Audit of Privatisation
Which region do you represent?
Are you a member of the Privatisation Working Group (PWG)?
Which issue is currently most topical in your country?
How much experience do you have auditing or reporting on the value for money of Privatisation?
How much experience do you have auditing or reporting on the value for money of Public Private Partnerships (PPP)?
How much experience do you have auditing or reporting on the value for money of
Economic Regulation of Privatised Businesses?
Does your SAI have a dedicated team for Privatisation/PPP/Regulation and if so how many auditors are within the team?
PPPs in Germany: a political framework
Does your country have targets for PPP
investments?
If your country has targets for PPP investments do
you find them useful?
Does your country have manuals and/or guidance on
appraising investments?
Does your country have 'centres of
competence'?
PPPs: A Bangladesh Perspective
In which of the following sectors is PPP most commmonplace in your country?
New Experience of the Audits of PPPs in Hungary
Do you think Long-term Development ranking of proposed PPPs before parliamentary approval is necessary?
Do you think that this type of rule is efficient?
Is the new rule more efficient than the old?
Construction of student hostels - Does this PPP meet the
Requirements/Suitability to business needs test?
Construction of student hostels - Does this PPP meet the Appropriateness of PPP
test?
Construction of student hostels - Does this PPP meet the Support of the project
by partners test?
Construction of student hostels - Does this PPP meet the Quality of delivery of project test?
Construction of student hostels - Does this PPP meet the Optimal balance between cost and equality test?
Construction of student hostels - Does this PPP meet the Effective risk
allocation test?
Risk Analysis in Regulatory Agencies for
Infrastructure Services
Does your SAL have a methodology for assessing risk within the Regulation
Agencies?
Could a risk based approach be usefully applied in your country?
Have your SAI been involved in cooperative audits?
Are you planning to/Do you want to participate in cooperative audits?
Government’s Interaction with capital markets
Have there been refinancings of private finance deals in your country?
Risk Analysis in Regulatory Agencies for Infrastructure Services
Does your SAL have a methodology for assessing risk within the Regulation Agencies?
Could a risk based approach be usefully applied in your country?
Have your SAI been involved in cooperative audits?
Are you planning to/Do you want to participate in cooperative audits?
Government’s Interaction with capital markets
Have there been refinancings of private finance deals in your country?
If yes to the above, has the state benefited financially from the refinancing?
