HMRC has improved how it manages debts owed to it by taxpayers, according to a report by the National Audit Office. The amount of money owed has reduced from 4.3 per cent of tax collected in 2005-06 to 3.8 per cent in 2007-08. The age of the direct tax debt has also reduced. Over the past year the level and age of debt has increased on some taxes, however, and the total number of debts has risen by 22 per cent.
HMRC collected around £450 billion in 2007-08 in tax and National Insurance contributions from the UK’s 35 million taxpayers, ranging from individuals to large multinational corporations. In March 2008, £21.5 billion was outstanding on its debt management systems. £17.3 billion was in outstanding tax, interest and penalties whilst the remainder was overpayments of benefits and tax credits.
The total number of debts has risen by 22 per cent, from 13 million to 15.8 million in the past year. In part the increase reflects an increase in the number of taxpayers and wider trends in consumer debt; but it also reflects a change in HMRC’s priorities as it focuses on higher value debts with fewer resources.
In 2007-08, HMRC’s Debt Management and Banking directorate collected around £310 for every £1 spent, an increase of 10 per cent on the year before. But HMRC cannot reliably measure the relative cost-effectiveness of different debt collection activities.
HMRC has yet to introduce some of the measures recommended by the Committee of Public Accounts in its previous report on debt, which have also helped other organisations to improve their debt management. Measures include risk profiling; managing debt through a single IT system; linking and pursuing together debts owed by an individual taxpayer on different taxes; innovative methods for communicating with customers; and a more efficient telephone centre operation. HMRC has developmental work underway, but the scale and pace of change has been restricted as other programmes take higher priority on funding. Such measures could however save money, through getting in more revenue and lower collection costs, and could help the Department better manage the growing level of debt.