There is a shortfall of 5,170 (2.8 per cent) trained Armed Forces personnel against the Ministry of Defence’s estimated requirements. Only the Army is within “manning balance”, and there are wider shortages of personnel in specific trade groups.
According to today’s report to Parliament, by head of the National Audit Office Sir John Bourn, there are particular challenges to manning levels in 88 specialist ‘pinch points’ – areas where there are insufficient trained personnel. These pinch points include doctors, nurses, engineers and bomb disposal experts.
The Department has achieved 98 per cent of its recruitment targets overall since 2000-2001. In 2005-06 it achieved 96 per cent of its target overall, including for over half of the pinch point trades surveyed by the National Audit Office. The Department has introduced a range of measures to improve recruitment.
The National Audit Office has also reported that the numbers of those leaving the Forces early have increased slightly in the last two years and that last year 9,200 personnel left early, although the Department considers that overall the long-term trend remains stable given historical levels of outflow. Of those surveyed by the National Audit Office who had recently left the Armed Forces, many had done so because of the impact of service on family life (49 per cent), while others reported the impact of too many deployments (28 per cent), the quality of the equipment (32 per cent), and a feeling of not being valued (33 per cent) as being important factors in their decision to leave. 9 per cent also said they had left because they had not been deployed enough.
Current levels of operational activity puts additional pressures on serving personnel in terms of hours worked, how often they are deployed and time spent away from families. We found that the Department’s guidelines on separated service were being exceeded by a significant number of personnel in the Army, where 14.5 per cent of the trained strength as at January 2006 had exceeded the guidelines at some point in the last 30 months.
The Ministry of Defence has introduced a number of financial retention incentives schemes and a range of other measures to improve manning in pinch point areas, aimed at retaining its most experienced personnel and alleviating some of the pressures in other groups.
On the basis of the limited evidence available, the National Audit Office concludes that retention measures appear to represent better value for money than recruitment, although both recruitment and retention are clearly important in maintaining the right profile of experience in the Armed Forces. The National Audit Office believes savings of £24 million could be made if planned retention levels were met. The report also estimates that it costs £74 million to retain 2,500 trained personnel against £189 million to recruit and provide initial training in basic military skills for the same number of new people.