Background to the report
The UK tax system had 1,190 tax reliefs (as at October 2019). A tax relief reduces the tax an individual or business owes. There are two broad categories of tax reliefs: structural tax reliefs that are largely integral parts of the tax system and define the scope and structure of tax (such as the personal tax allowance); and non-structural tax reliefs where government opts not to collect tax to pursue social or economic objectives.Jump to downloads
Non-structural tax reliefs are often referred to as ‘tax expenditures’. Examples include tax credits for companies’ research and development (R&D) costs and income tax relief on pension contributions. Some tax expenditures simply reflect a policy choice by ministers to support particular groups or sectors (for example the housing market), while others are designed to incentivise behaviour. Some tax reliefs can be difficult to classify because they have more than one objective and include elements of both tax expenditures and structural reliefs.
Tax expenditures are an important part of public policy design. They cover most areas of government activity, including welfare, housing, business, food, education, health and transport. They can also make the tax system more complicated and less transparent, and they could pose risks to public finances because their costs can rise beyond expectations. Tax expenditures differ from public spending in that they reduce the amount of tax collected, rather than consume resources after tax is collected. However, they are similar in that both affect the public purse and can be used to pursue discrete policy objectives.
Content and scope of the report
This report examines the effectiveness of HM Treasury’s and HMRC’s use of their resources in the management of tax expenditures. Government spending is governed by HM Treasury’s Managing Public Money but there is no equivalent guidance for tax expenditures. The rules governing the tax system are set out in legislation which Parliament scrutinises through the Finance Bill process. The exchequer departments provide information needed to support decision-making. How the exchequer departments monitor and evaluate tax expenditures informs government’s understanding of the value for money of tax expenditures. In this report we examine how HM Treasury and HMRC manage tax expenditures overall and examine their oversight and administration across the lifecycle of tax expenditures, specifically:
- the number and cost of tax expenditures;
- design and monitoring of tax expenditures; and
- the evaluation and review of tax expenditures.
At a forecast cost of £155 billion in 2018-19, tax expenditures represent an important means by which government pursues economic and social objectives. Evaluations show that their impact is not guaranteed, and many require careful monitoring. We have previously raised concerns about how effectively government is managing tax expenditures. Both HMRC and HM Treasury have responded to our recommendations by increasing their oversight of tax expenditures and actively considering their value for money.
While these steps are welcome, they are very much still in development. The large number of tax expenditures means it will take time to identify and embed good practices. Both departments need to make substantial progress and ensure sufficient coverage and rigour in the work they undertake on this matter.
On their own these improvements will not be sufficient to address value-for‑money concerns unless the departments formally establish their accountabilities for tax expenditures and enable greater transparency. Lessons can be learned from other countries that have established clear arrangements for evaluating and reporting on tax expenditures. We look to HM Treasury and HMRC to follow suit by clarifying arrangements for value for money and improving the evaluation and public reporting of tax expenditures.
- Report - The management of tax expenditures (.pdf — 519 KB)
- Summary - The management of tax expenditures (.pdf — 112 KB)
- ePub - The management of tax expenditures (.epub — 2 MB)
- ISBN: 9781786043016 [Buy a hard copy of this report]
- HC: 46, 2019-20