Background to the report
For generations coins and notes have played a central role in society as the primary means of payment. Over £100 billion is spent in shops using coins and notes every year and until 2017 cash was the most frequently used payment method in the UK. The use of cash in transactions is, however, in decline: 10 years ago, cash was used in six out of 10 transactions, and last year it was less than three in 10. Forecasts have suggested that this might fall to one in 10 by 2028. A recent drop in the use of cash during the COVID-19 pandemic may accelerate that trend.Jump to downloads
The continuing reduction in the use of cash in transactions is putting pressure on the cash system. Many of the costs of cash production and distribution are fixed. Commercial operators have warned of pressures on their business models, which have previously depended on higher cash volumes to maintain the commercial attractiveness of their operations. Consumer organisations have raised concerns that reductions in the ability of people to access cash, and increasing costs to business of using cash, if not properly managed, may increase the risk of financial exclusion for sections of society dependent on cash.
Scope of the report
This report examines the role played by the public bodies in operating and overseeing the cash system at a time of rapid change in society’s use of cash. We assess:
- how the cash system currently operates in the UK;
- whether the key public bodies have clear objectives and responsibilities for delivering the government’s aims for the cash system, and adequate information on how well the system meets consumer needs, and the action taken to deliver the government’s aims; and
- how well the Mint, on behalf of HM Treasury, and the Bank oversee and manage coin and note production respectively, and the extent to which they have reduced the threat of counterfeiting.
The declining use of cash is placing increasing pressure on the sustainability of the infrastructure for producing and distributing cash. The current approach to overseeing the cash system is fragmented with no clear link between HM Treasury’s overall objective of safeguarding access to cash for those who need it, the outcome that public bodies want to see and the costs associated with that outcome, and the responsibilities of the individual public bodies involved in the cash system. The creation of the coordination group has brought together the key public bodies and helped improve their understanding of the end-to-end cash system. They have been commissioning research to understand consumer needs, but they have yet to establish information systems to track the impact of a rapidly changing cash system on consumers, particularly for disadvantaged consumers whose needs may be greater. The government’s recent announcement to introduce legislation with regard to access to cash, alongside other measures, may provide an opportunity to address some of the issues raised in this report.
The Mint and the Bank share similar objectives for the production of coins and notes but deliver against those objectives in very different ways. Both have been successful in maintaining public confidence in cash against the threat of counterfeiting. However, both have accumulated significant stocks of coins and notes in the face of very different patterns of demand. With the use of cash in transactions in rapid decline, and with the recent renewal of coins and note types now almost complete, the Mint and the Bank need to align their production operations much more closely to likely future needs if they are to demonstrate value for money.
“As society progresses towards the wide use of digital payments, the use of cash in transactions is dwindling. It may become harder for people to access cash when they need it and those without the means to pay digitally will struggle if cash is not accepted.
“HM Treasury now works more closely with the public bodies in the cash system to achieve the government’s goal of safeguarding access to cash. However, the approach is fragmented, and it is not clear that the action being taken will keep up with the pace of change.”Gareth Davies, head of the NAO
- Report - The production and distribution of cash (.pdf — 707 KB)
- Summary - The production and distribution of cash (.pdf — 132 KB)
- Pub - The production and distribution of cash (.epub — 1 MB)
- ISBN: 9781786043344 [Buy a hard copy of this report]
- HC: 730, 2019-21
View press release (18 Sep 2020)